Need help for a gift for my brothers wedding! Please Help

  • Ragnarok
    Topic creator
    Joined: 02.10.2017Posts: 1Ratings: 0

    Hello all,

    I am in need of some help in deciding on a bottle of scotch to gift my brother for his wedding. My lack of knowledge on the subject is abysmal as you can probably tell from my lack of knowing the difference between scotch, whiskey, and bourbon.

    So if you could help, I would greatly appreciate it.

    List of some scotch/whiskeys/bourbons that he drinks:

    • The Macallan 18 year
    • Hudson Four Grain Bourbon
    • The GlenDronach 12 year
    • Glenfiddich Malt Masters Edition Single Malt
    • Tincup Mountain Whiskey
    • The Most Righteous (It's a New York Catskills Distilling Company)
    • New York State Yankee Bourbon Whiskey

    He said he likes his scotch matured in a sherry cask. He likes low quality rye as he said the high quality ryes are too spicy and biting for him.

    I had thought about "The Macallan Rare Cask", however I have read that is a bit spicy so I took that off the list. I also wanted to be original and avoid the standard "I don't know anything about scotch so here is a bottle of Johnny Blue" gift. Not saying Johnny Blue is anything to scoff at, however I want it to be special and original. 

    I was suggested a bottle of Glenfarclas Family Cask 1996 however, he hasn't heard of this brand before so I am hesitant to spend a lot of money on something he has never heard of before. 

    I could get him another bottle of The Macallan 18 year but like I said, I'd like to be original. 

    My budget on this is 250-300 USD, however I'd be willing to spend up to 350 if necessary. 

    Any and all help will be appreciated. 

    Thank you!

  • thepeanut Member Joined: 17.08.2015Posts: 30CollectionThePeanuts CollectionRatings: 8

    @Ragnarok I might be biased but I'll pick Macallan 18 or Glenfiddich Malt Masters

    New Whiskey Drinker
  • bedlamborn Member bedlamborn Joined: 18.09.2016Posts: 611Collectionbedlamborns CollectionRatings: 21


    If he likes Glendronach then for example Glendronach 18 or 21 year old could be a good choice. Or even a GlenDronach single cask relase with some age.

    kroman liked that
  • kroman Member Joined: 16.04.2016Posts: 260Collectionkromans CollectionRatings: 21

    I agree with a glendronach 21 or single cask. Here are some other options that might do the job, but also come in nice display cases / shapped bottles, as this is a special event.  All of these have some sherry influence in them

    Other options:

    Glenlivet 25

    Dalmore King Alexander III

    Glenglassaugh 30 (glen-GLASS-aww)  This distillery is owned by the same people who make Glendronach

    The Glenfarclas would also be a great choice.  Even though he hasn't heard of them, I'm sure he'll like it.

    Bunnahabhain (BOO-na-ha-vin) 25 would also be a fantastic choice and comes in a beautiful case.  I'm sure he hasn't heard of it, but it's one of my favorite distilleries and has a healthy ammount of sherry influence.  this might be too expensive, though.

    so, if you want original, go bunnahabhain or glenglassaugh

    if you want classy, go dalmore

    if you want sherry, go glendronach 21

    if you want a "safer" bet, go glenlivet.

    All will have great flavor, so don't worry about that aspect 

    Also keep in mind that prices will vary WIDELY depending on where you are at

Sign In or Register to comment.