Peated and Unpeated Whiskies

Scotch single malt whisky can be classified into two main flavours: peated (smoky) and unpeated (non-smoky). The smoky aroma in whisky results from the method of drying the malt. If the malt is dried over a peat fire, the components of the peat smoke that have not been completely turned into carbon dioxide and water vapour adhere to the malt. These aromatic compounds are transported through all production steps into the finished whisky.

In contrast, the malt for unpeated whisky is dried with hot air without any smoke. The preferences for one of the two production methods are distributed quite asymmetrically among the consumers. A majority of connoisseurs like both peated and unpeated whiskies. Another fraction prefers peated whisky and tolerates unpeated whisky. However, a non-negligible percentage of connoisseurs do not like peated whisky. Therefore different sets of peated, unpeated and mixed whisky samples were offered to the participants, thus making sure that each participant received the type of whisky they liked best.

This approach made sure that no whiskies were rated poorly due to individual preferences or dislikes. Perhaps this approach is also the reason why the mean value of the quality ratings (3.3 to 3.5 points) was 0.3 to 0.5 scale points (7.5% to 12.5%) above the middle of the scale (3.0). Perhaps the reason for these ratings above the mean value was that the participants liked the samples a bit more than the average of the whiskies they know. But maybe the blind tasting was just so interesting and unusual that the whiskies were rated slightly better than average.

Table 6. Statistical summary of the results for peated bottlings

Peated samples Count Percent
Amount of samples 551 41,4%
Amount of chill filtered samples 274 49,7%
Amount of non chill filtered samples 277 50,3%
positive identified chill filtrations 110 40,1%
non positive identified chill filtrations 164 59,9%
positive identified non chill filtrations 162 58,5%
non positive identified non chill filtrations 113 40,8%
positive identified filtrations 272 49,4%
non positive identified filtrations 277 50,3%

Mean
Average quality chill filtration 3,5
Average quality non chill filtration 3,5

There are significantly fewer peated than unpeated whiskies on the market. Due to this lower availability only 41.1% of all samples were peated. However, the 551 samples were still enough to get a significant result. It is interesting that the smoke in the aroma is perceived by the consumer like non chill filtration. It remains unclear whether there is an influence on the taste or whether the test person makes a better guess because there are many non chill filtered peated single malt whiskies. Only 40.1% of the samples were correctly identified as chill filtered. This is significantly less than the variation around the 'guessed' mean value of 50% that could be seen in the tables above. The percentage of correctly identified non chill filtration is accordingly high (58.5%).

Irrespective of the filtration method, the quality of peated whiskies is rated better than the aggregate of all samples by 0.1 scale points (2.5%).

Table 7. Statistical summary of the results for unpeated bottlings

Unpeated samples Count Percent
Amount of samples 780 58,6%
Amount of chill filtered samples 390 50,0%
Amount of non chill filtered samples 390 50,0%
positive identified chill filtrations 202 51,8%
non positive identified chill filtrations 188 48,2%
positive identified non chill filtrations 204 52,3%
non positive identified non chill filtrations 186 47,7%
positive identified filtrations 406 52,1%
non positive identified filtrations 374 47,9%

Mean
Average quality chill filtration 3,3
Average quality non chill filtration 3,3

The result for the unpeated whiskies shows the opposite picture. The participants were more often able to correctly identify the method of filtration for unpeated whiskies. The identification rate is only 52.1%, but both the values for correctly identified chill filtration and non chill filtration are on the positive side, with 51.8% and 52.3% respectively.

Even if this tendency was established for 780 samples, it is just a small tendency 'slightly above guessing' (2.1%) and must not be overrated. 

The Whisky Database

See the vast collection of whiskys and whiskeys from around the world

The Forum

Meet other whisky lovers, exchange knowledge and facts about whisky.

The Whisky Blog

Horst Luening tastes all the whiskys in the world. You will find everything about whisky and whiskey.

Knowledge

Study on the Chill Filtration of Scotch Single Malt Whiskies

Does Chill Filtration effect the Taste of Scotch Whisky? This is answered in a Scientific paper written by Horst Luening.

Whisky Label Lore

Learn about how what a whisky bottle label tells you about the Scotch, Bourbon or Irish whiskey inside.

Scotch - Bottling

Read an overview about how Scottish Single Malt whisky is bottled by the distillery or the independent bottlers. Learn about the different ABV levels...

Irish - Distillation

Irish Whiskey distillation Contents Irish Whiskey distillation 1. Pot...

The Scottish Pot Stills

Read about the Scottish pot stills. Learn about the Wash-, Intermediate-, and the Spirit still. See the different sizes and shapes and how the reflux...