I have not had any of the Islay you are asking about but from the reading I have done these would be my choices in order of preference.
Highland Park 12 yo
Laphroaig 10 yo
Bunnahabain 12 yo
The other list you have below that are non Islay and non peaty. From the ones on the list these would be my recommendations.
Glenmorangie 10
Glennfiddich 12
Macallan 10
Any other questions let me know.
|