Originally Posted by TheEtherMan
These "Sams Club" Macallans are from old stock that Macallan **** off to independent bottlers and/or blenders, who now **** it on to whoever bottles this stuff. (Glentaite)
I have not tried it, but as will ALL independent bottlings, you never really know what you're going to get. It could be devine, revealing complexity not normally seen in standard bottling, or it could be hopelessly flawed. I would bet this is from a vetting of several casks, to generate enough volume to bother bottling and distributing. It has not passed the quality testing that a Macallan produced product would to insure a consistent flavor profile. With that in mind, even if one vatting is good, the next may be very different.
Mark Gillespie of the whiskycast did a review of a sams Macallan, and while it got a fair score, it was far below the score of the official distillery bottlings. I can't remember the scores, but they should be online.
If you give it a go, post a review.
Thanks for the info , I was going to give it a shot for $50 but I don't really know if I would care for it .Since I heard most Mccallan is fruity tasting and I'm currently looking for something without the fruit blast.