Although not a huge Islay fan myself - I liked Laphroaig Quarter Cask from the very first try. I noticed that sweetness right off the bat - and was really impressed. Thanks for all of your input here everyone - I
really enjoy hearing what all of you have to say!
And BTW nighthawk - when you say, "I'm betting Jojo would try that too, I know she has mentioned that she likes chocolate with Scotch." - you are absolutely right!