Who in their right mind would want to ditch Michelle?
Seriously, if you have found your own PDN (personal divine nectar) in the Lagavulin 16, why bother with trying to find something else to replace it?
I wish I could narrow it down that well. It would make shopping so much simpler. As it is, I have a half dozen whiskies on my favorites list, and the one at the very top is nearly always the one I'm sipping at the time.