I've had the A'bunadh Batch 44 recently and the Doublewood 12 a few years ago. The A'bunadh was richer and fuller for sherry, obviously. But I don't know if it quite lives up to its billing. Both are good round drams and I think the A'bunadh edges the Doublewood, but neither knocks your socks off
. I've not had the Doublewood 17 since it's a bit outside my current price range.