Originally Posted by David_T
My two favorite lassies, for now anyway. I've been dating them on alternating evenings.
My current tasting wish list includes The Dalmore 15, Glenfiddich 15, Glenmorangie Nectar d'Or, Glenfarclas 17, The Macallan 15 Fine Oak and The Balvenie 17 Doublewood.
However, I'm not motivated enough to buy a lot of singles right now. The next tasting event for me will be at the West Virginia Highland Games the first weekend in May. We'll see what they have...
Not on my list, but have you tried Talsiker 18? From the reviews I've read, it sounds like you might like it.
I hope to have a chance at many of the ones you've listed here, if for no other reason than your recommendation, but what I have found is that older bottlings have been outside my preference range up till now.
That said, I'm always a fan of verifying whether I like something or not and your endorsement is not taken lightly, though I will say that my not overly pleasant experience with the Fine Oak 12, not to mention others suggestions to avoid all Fine Oak's has me closer to the sidelines on them in particular.