Funny you should mention Clynelish
Funny you should mention Clynelish, farr. I just picked up a bottle of Clynelish 14yr today, along with a Springbank 10yr. The Springbank was okay, and definately had some salty tones, but I much preferred the Clynelish. Subtly salty, and light, the Clynelish was a great dram, and contrasted well with the Laphroaig I mentioned in my original post.
Thanks to TheEtherMan for the numerous suggestions as well! I nearly picked up a bottle of Old Pulteney 12 to go with the Springbank, but the fellow I spoke with at the store introduced me to the Clynelish instead. However, Old Pulteney 12 is still on my short list!