I think you would probably like the Highland Park 18. it is a good mix of honey sweet and lovely smoke, without a big peaty bite. It's not sherried whisky though, it gets it's honey sweetness from bourbon barrels.
You could also blend your own. It looks like you have everything you need to get going. The peat and smoke from Laphroaig will spice up any of those other whiskies. Keep in mind that a few drops might be all you need in an oz of the primary whisky. I blend my own all the time. Custom for your palate.
AUDENTES FORTUNA IUVAT
"60% of the time, it works every time."