The suspense is killing me on trying some Uigeadail. I know it'll be up my alley, as I'm a big fan of Lagavulin 16, Ardbeg 10, and of course Talisker and Laphroaig's offerings (sipping on some Talisker DE 2000 right now).
So at the moment it's Laga 16 but I have a pretty good feeling it'll be Uigeadail soon.
That being said, I echo the notion that there can't reaaally be one to rule them all. If it weren't for different moods calling for different drams, we wouldn't need these silly collections so many of us have (mine is rather small compared to some I'm sure, but still takes a few minutes to paw through before deciding some days).