Thank you for the suggestions! And Jojo, I promised no spamming, and I'm sticking to that promise!!
I ended up picking up Ardbeg Ten as well as Highland Park 12. I'm off of work for over a week, so I have a lot of time for tasting!
I did break into the Highland Park and liked it quite a bit. It was far more smoky than I have had, but I enjoyed it very much. Thanks again!