JCP and Michael Thank You for the suggestions! I had not considered Highland Park, but seems to be a HUGE favorite! Might have to sneak a bottle of it in this Christmas...
Michael, I was warned that Ardbeg was a "real man's" Scotch, so as a newb, I am a bit nervous. Also seems to be a bit hard to find in this area... I'll keep my eye out for it.
Speaking of Christmas Scotch... phone pic attached.